Fair Market Value & Buyback Windows Compared (2026)
How Courtyard, PrizePicks, Underdog, Triumph, OG.com, Collector Crypt, Phygitals, Arena Club and Boxed.gg set fair market value — and how long you have to sell back.
Why '100% of FMV' isn't the same everywhere
Almost every rip site lets you sell a pull back instantly. The headline number — 85%, 90%, 100% — is a percentage of a fair market value (FMV) that the operator sets itself. Two sites both paying '100% of FMV' can offer very different money for the same card if their FMV estimates differ.
So compare three things: the rate, who sets the price it's applied to, and how long the offer stays open. How you get paid (cash, USDC or site credit) matters too.
Operator by operator
- Courtyard — about 85–90% of FMV with a 7-day decision window. RotoWire cites a published 90%; CardWire measured 84.6% in testing. Zero-fee marketplace listing is often the better route for big hits.
- PrizePicks Packs — advertised 100% of FMV sellback. PrizePicks hasn't published how its FMV is calculated or a fixed window, so check in-app.
- Underdog Rips — 100% of FMV per Underdog's help pages. Regular packs auto-sell after 3 days; $1 packs and promo or discounted packs auto-sell after 60 minutes.
- Rips by Triumph — 100% of a Triumph-set value, 7-day vault window. Reviewers note Triumph's values may not match open-market prices.
- OG.com Rips — instant buyback offered, but no rate or FMV method has been published yet. Treat the offer as unknown until you see it.
- Collector Crypt — 85–93% of insured value, 72-hour window, paid in USDC. Gacha Report measured roughly 94¢ back per dollar at buyback.
- Phygitals — 85–100% of FMV instant buyback; new users get a 100% boost, per Win.gg.
- Arena Club — 90% (100% value minus a 10% fee), but only a 24-hour window. PackRipper calls these the clearest terms it found.
- Boxed.gg — 100% of its own gem value, paid in gems rather than cash, so the money stays on the site.
Quick takeaways
- Longest windows: Courtyard and Triumph (7 days). Shortest: Underdog $1 and promo packs (60 minutes) and Arena Club (24 hours).
- Most transparent pricing: Collector Crypt (published value bands) and Arena Club (explicit fee).
- Least disclosed: OG.com and PrizePicks, both launched recently.
- Cash vs credit: Boxed.gg pays gems; Collector Crypt pays USDC; most others pay into a cash wallet.
How to check a buyback before you rip
- Look up a recent sold price for the card (eBay sold listings, PSA auction prices) and compare it to the offer.
- Note the window — set a reminder if it's short.
- Check whether payout is withdrawable cash or site credit.
- For high-value pulls, compare buyback with listing on a marketplace.
A note on accuracy
Rates and windows change often, and most operators don't publish their FMV method. This guide summarises the sources below as of November 2026 — confirm current terms in each app.
Sources
- RotoWire — Courtyard review
- CardWire — Courtyard review
- PrizePicks — official Packs page
- Underdog — What is Underdog Rips?
- RipFacts — Rips by Triumph buyback facts
- Saturday Down South — OG Rips review
- Gacha Report — Collector Crypt
- Win.gg — Phygitals review
- PackRipper — Is Arena Club legit?
- MyCardRips — Boxed.gg review
Ready to compare operators?
See the comparison table →